#1 January 7th 2009 9:53 AM - Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

gotoET
Goat
From: schweden
Registered: 06/21/07

I never thought I would do this. smile

For his new single on Island Records, Frankmusik sampled a 1993 SID-tune by Jeff. It is not the biggest of deals, but come on - give the guy some credit!

http://chipflip.wordpress.com/2009/01/0 … lagiarism/


+ + + - + / + + = 1
 

Offline

#2 January 7th 2009 10:23 AM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Stevens
Member
From: Bromley
Registered: 04/11/08

HAHA!

This guy's playing the BBCKS LULZ1!!1100 event!

Oh the irony! 'Best thing to happen to the chipscene'...

Also 5 SID versions of 'Popcorn'? That's hilarious!!


FOLLOW THAT DOLPHIN!
www.myspace.com/stevenosurname
 

Offline

#3 January 7th 2009 2:54 PM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Infotoxin
Member
From: Belfast, Ireland
Registered: 12/27/08

Another reason to hat frankmusik... like I needed one. Meh.

5 SID popcorn covers... In court no less. Fairly surreal I imagine. big_smile


Science: "What are birds? We just don't know..." - Look Around You, Module 2
 

Offline

#4 January 7th 2009 3:55 PM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

arlen
Guest

Fuck! Not another one. I had a feeling this guy sampled stuff. Damn bastard.

 

#5 January 7th 2009 5:00 PM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Pompei
Member
From: Detroit, MI
Registered: 02/01/08

of course, one of my favorite artists had to sample a song.

 

Offline

#6 January 7th 2009 5:11 PM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Pompei
Member
From: Detroit, MI
Registered: 02/01/08

so listened to 3 little words on my ipod at 2:20, and i could not hear jeffs song. though i did hear it on the first version of 3 little words he made. (which is on youtube) On his new version of the song that is also on youtube it seems that he's taken the sample out. and im pretty sure the new version is the version he had on his new album.

if i am wrong correct me?

 

Offline

#7 January 7th 2009 7:19 PM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Oxygenfad
Member
From: Canada
Registered: 12/03/07

N = X + (0:01 to 0:07 + 1:10 to 1:20) + (Hair, Shirt, Vocals)

I'm sure he's a nice guy though ...

Last edited by Oxygenfad (January 7th 2009 7:42 PM)

 

Offline

#8 January 7th 2009 9:26 PM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

minusbaby
El Varón de Todos
From: NY NY USA
Registered: 06/14/07

^ That makes me want to fight.

 

Offline

#9 January 7th 2009 10:11 PM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

bleepbloop
Jose Angel
From: NY, USA
Registered: 08/08/06

^^hahahahahahaha BWahahahahahaha

wait is that for real?

 

Offline

#10 January 7th 2009 10:15 PM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

infradead
Member
From: tacoma, wa
Registered: 12/09/07

i wonder if jazz and funk guys would have had discussions like this when hip hop started out if the internet was around?

 

Offline

#11 January 7th 2009 10:38 PM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

goatslacker
Member
From: Miami, FL
Registered: 12/06/07

Holy crap what is wrong with Alice's face?!

 

Offline

#12 January 8th 2009 12:54 AM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Astro
Member
Registered: 04/10/08

What song/s did Crystal Castle's rip off ?

 

Offline

#13 January 8th 2009 1:20 AM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

gotoET
Goat
From: schweden
Registered: 06/21/07

pokemon posers wrote:

so listened to 3 little words on my ipod at 2:20, and i could not hear jeffs song. though i did hear it on the first version of 3 little words he made. (which is on youtube) On his new version of the song that is also on youtube it seems that he's taken the sample out. and im pretty sure the new version is the version he had on his new album.

if i am wrong correct me?

it seemed a bit like that to me too, but it's weird to keep it in the video version. does anyone have the single or the album to verify?

infraded wrote:

i wonder if jazz and funk guys would have had discussions like this when hip hop started out if the internet was around?

nobody beats the pickiness and nerdiness of us chip mongos! no doubt the jazz/funk/r&b-people would get quite busy if they would take the challenge though. i'm guessing their publishers or copyright holders are paying close attention these days though...


+ + + - + / + + = 1
 

Offline

#16 January 8th 2009 8:27 AM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Matt
Member
From: London, UK
Registered: 05/25/07

Just to add, the sample's on his early, home made (demo?) version that appeared a year or so back. The re-recorded version he's done since signing to Island does NOT contain the sample. Am sure this small fact will not however prevent a ten page thread full of hand wringing over how a major label artist is dicking over the scene though. Maybe i'm a bit biased though, i think 3 Little Words is a bloody ace song.

 

Offline

#17 January 8th 2009 8:30 AM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

J&HT
Member
From: UK, Huddersfield
Registered: 08/16/08

Matt wrote:

Just to add, the sample's on his early, home made (demo?) version that appeared a year or so back. The re-recorded version he's done since signing to Island does NOT contain the sample. Am sure this small fact will not however prevent a ten page thread full of hand wringing over how a major label artist is dicking over the scene though. Maybe i'm a bit biased though, i think 3 Little Words is a bloody ace song.

See also: Crystal Castles and their 'demo' songs :p

 

Offline

#18 January 8th 2009 8:36 AM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Subway Sonicbeat
esc-lover
From: São Paulo, Brasil
Registered: 05/16/08

Frankmusik is supported by babycakes?
Someone said that to me, I might be wrong.

But, probably the case is solved...? Or not?

EDIT: Oh, and:

akira||8GB wrote:

What is it with this people????
Is it so hard to say "sampled XXXX from XXX" ?????

Is it? Just change it on the youtube video, everyone would be happy, for fuck sake!

EDIT2: moment of confusion. Sorry.

Last edited by Subway Sonicbeat (January 8th 2009 8:51 AM)


Site || Myspace || Tumblr || CHIPPANZE || Trama

~-('-'ºç) <NINJA!)
 

Offline

#19 January 8th 2009 8:45 AM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Matt
Member
From: London, UK
Registered: 05/25/07

JA92 wrote:

See also: Crystal Castles and their 'demo' songs :p

Well, to be fair, I found that whole hoo-hah a little overcooked as well, considering the CC/Lo-Bat tracks were on their (secondary) Myspace page and not the album. I mean, if we're going to be *that* fastidious about where samples come from then I'd be fascinated to see the agreement that Sabrepulse and about 95% of first-time uploaders on 8BC reached with The Winstons that permitted them to use the Amen break over all their tracks... wink

*steps back and admires freshly opened can of worms*

 

Offline

#20 January 8th 2009 8:47 AM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Matt
Member
From: London, UK
Registered: 05/25/07

Having said that, I agree with Akira that it's not hard to credit where samples are from, it's a common courtesy and he should have done it.

Subway Sonicbeat, do you have me confused with someone else...?

 

Offline

#21 January 8th 2009 8:50 AM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Subway Sonicbeat
esc-lover
From: São Paulo, Brasil
Registered: 05/16/08

Matt wrote:

Having said that, I agree with Akira that it's not hard to credit where samples are from, it's a common courtesy and he should have done it.

Subway Sonicbeat, do you have me confused with someone else...?

OH DUDE, sorry!
Yes, i did tongue


Site || Myspace || Tumblr || CHIPPANZE || Trama

~-('-'ºç) <NINJA!)
 

Offline

#22 January 8th 2009 9:57 AM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

DJCactus
Member
From: Novi Mi
Registered: 08/15/08

remember when  half the world wanted to sue puff daddy because he plagiarized everyone, but nothing happened.  I dont think people care enough for the community, theyd rather have the credit for the bad ass sound, but remember, if anyone asks them to reproduce this sound, alls they can do is show someone the internet.


insert a statement about inserting a statement here.
 

Offline

#24 January 8th 2009 1:53 PM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Subway Sonicbeat
esc-lover
From: São Paulo, Brasil
Registered: 05/16/08

coldplay stole from a lot of people.

And i like that song, but ii hate joe satriani. sad


Site || Myspace || Tumblr || CHIPPANZE || Trama

~-('-'ºç) <NINJA!)
 

Offline

#25 January 8th 2009 2:56 PM - Re: Yet Another Plagiarism (sorry) Frankmusik+Jeff

Hot Mess
Guest

Nickelback stole from Nickelback.